By Alison Mitchell, Ph.D. & David Rose

The promise of education is not only to supply students with skills and knowledge, but also to foster the ability to problem-solve in the classroom and beyond. Student mindset has been theorized as a meaningful factor on this front. More specifically, the idea that students with a higher tendency toward a growth mindset – those who more strongly believe that their abilities can be developed through learning and effort – are more motivated to persist through rigorous challenges.

Given this perspective, many educators have been incorporating strategies to bolster growth mindset into their interactions with students in their classrooms. With the common use of educational technology in the classroom, understanding how these tools might support student perspectives on learning can provide further opportunity to put these approaches into practice for both students and their teachers.

Growth Mindset 

The initial emphasis on mindset research was popularized by the work of Dr. Carol Dweck, a professor at Stanford University, who spent decades examining how students’ own theories of intelligence reflect their behavioral and psychological response to academic challenges. Along with her colleagues, she found that a student’s approach to a challenge can vary. 

In its most simplified presentation, mindset theory suggests that students who possess a more fixed mindset are more likely to be preoccupied with the notion of high performance and will seek opportunities where they can prove their skills, while avoiding situations where their weaknesses might be revealed. On the other hand, students employing more of a growth-oriented mindset believe their abilities can develop over time and practice. This ideally leads them to seek out opportunities to gain new knowledge, broaden their skills, and not  immediately shy away from challenges.

As the field of mindset research has matured, questions have emerged around what it means to put this work into practice and for whom mindset interventions are most appropriate. Some structured intervention studies have suggested that mindset can impact student performance, but that the results are not equivalent across students; rather, influencing mindset may be most critical for those students with the most growth opportunity in a particular area to start. Dweck has also shared important distinctions around the process of fostering growth mindset, noting that emphasis on effort alone is not sufficient, but that it must be paired with a focus on strategies and results, allowing students to interrogate the effort and the road taken to achieve a particular result in order to support their resilience in learning. 

Outside the course of an intervention targeted to this area, developing and shifting students’ perspectives in this way is an iterative process that requires extended engagement across time and settings. While the teacher and student are always at the center of this process, this may include leveraging learning tools. Here are six ways educators and administrators can leverage educational technology to help cultivate a growth mindset in students: 

 

  1. Provide low-stakes practice opportunities. The brain is a muscle that needs exercise. Some students may focus on the appearance of strong performance and avoiding failure versus tackling challenges. Many educational technology tools, such as Lexia Core5, allow a student to set their own pace, monitor their own progress, and choose their own activities (with no one looking) from a curated list of options at the right difficulty level, which may result in students taking greater risks in their learning and persisting more on challenging activities when they fail.   

 

  1. Deliver continuous feedback. Effective educational technology programs provide continual feedback to students through animations and progress-monitoring indices, such as screens at the completion of a task acknowledging the student’s effort or a counter that shows how many activities are completed and remaining in a unit. Allowing students to see how much time they spent on an activity and giving them immediate, real-time reinforcement after persisting through challenging work can support a growth mindset. 

 

  1. Monitor and share accumulated learning. Logging into a program to see a visual representation of everything you’ve learned can have a big impact in building competence, reinforcing that knowledge is gained through effort and that deep learning is something achieved over time. The collected data can also be used as a discussion point between the student and the teacher to further support goal setting, progress-monitoring and the relationship between their extended efforts, their learning strategies and the results. 

 

  1. Identify which students need extra focus and prioritization. This continuous skill data gathered through ongoing learning via technology tools, without stopping for a separate testing session, can also supplement the information an educator has from the classroom to more quickly identify and prioritize which students need the most support and who may benefit most from continued coaching around their learning mindset. 

 

  1. Tailor individualized teacher intervention tools. Once students are identified as needing attention, tools that supply direct links to personalized teacher-led lessons grant the opportunity for students and educators to engage deeply in the right areas, at the right time, and investigate together which strategies are working for the student and where they need something new. This reinforces the connection between the student’s online work and teacher-led instruction in the classroom. 

 

  1. Foster supportive classrooms and school-to-home connections. Finally, teachers and students need to work together to grow everyone’s skills and knowledge. Continuous data helps students talk about where they are, where they have been, and where they are going. Students can celebrate each other’s successes, offer reassurances when there is a challenging task, and be peer mentors for one another.  

 

A Continuous Learning Process

Developing a growth mindset requires a continuous process of learning where students are given ongoing opportunities to engage with challenges and receive support in using new strategies to approach them. By treating the mind like any other muscle in the human body, we can encourage students to learn new skills, overcome challenges and strengthen their own knowledge-building. 

 

About the Authors:

Alison Mitchell, Ph.D. serves as the Sr. Director of Product Research and Assessment and David Rose is the Director of Education Partnerships for Lexia.