By Tom Woelper and Ross Peters
Every school has one somewhere: a strategic plan that took two years to write, earned warm applause at a board meeting, and then settled quietly onto a shelf or onto an obscure computer folder. Ask a veteran teacher about it, and you may get a knowing smile. Ask what it changed and the room goes quiet.
That smile is worth taking seriously. It is what is left behind by plans written for boards or accreditors rather than with the people who have to carry them out. Any leader starting a new planning process should expect that smile. The real work is making sure the next plan does not earn it.
Cheshire Academy came to this work from two directions. Tom has spent more than 30 years leading schools in the United States and abroad and is now in his second full year as Head of School at Cheshire Academy, a boarding and day school in Connecticut founded in 1794. After decades as a teacher and school leader, Ross has spent years advising heads of school and boards on strategy, governance, and leadership. Over the past 18 months, we worked together on Cheshire Academy’s new strategic plan, Individual Growth. Global Purpose, which the Board of Trustees approved in June 2026.
What follows are the lessons we would offer any school or district leader about to begin, public or independent, large or small. The short version: the document matters far less than the conversation that produces it and the conversation that keeps it alive.
Start by Listening
Every leader walks into strategic planning believing they already know the biggest issues. Usually they know some of them. The surprise is what people do not say until they are asked, and asked well.
At Cheshire Academy, the first step was not a goal-setting retreat. Before any formal process began, Ross spent three days on campus meeting with departments, staff, and students, leaving time for anyone to drop by. The purpose was simply to learn the school: its culture, its strengths, what people were proud of, and what worried them. Listening then became the structure of the process.
Our strategic planning process began with the mission. Before setting a single priority, a working group of faculty, staff, and trustees refreshed Cheshire Academy’s mission statement until every word could be mapped to something real in the school’s pedagogy, philosophy, or practice: “Cheshire Academy challenges and supports individual students in developing the character, critical thinking, and confidence to flourish as purposeful global citizens.” The order matters. A plan built on a mission no one has examined in years tends to optimize the wrong things. A mission the community has just argued over, and agreed on, gives every later conversation a shared reference point. It shows up in the plan’s own name: Individual Growth. Global Purpose. which is shorthand for the mission itself. The mission activates the plan, and the plan activates the mission.
The Board then named what we call the Two Non-Negotiables, the outcomes that must be true at the end of the plan for it to count as a success, a success that creates a competitive advantage: financial health strong enough to serve current students and generations to come, and a distinctive identity built on a high-caliber education in which expert faculty guide students’ ownership of their own pathways. From there, the Leadership Team, the full faculty, and a Strategic Planning Committee of trustees, faculty, and staff each worked the same question: What work needs to happen to bring these non-negotiables to life?
At a full-day faculty in-service, Ross first put teachers in mixed groups across departments, then regrouped them by department to ask how the priorities would change their own work. Regular surveys of parents and employees added more voices.
Not everything we heard was comfortable. Faculty named the gap between the school’s aspirations and its resources more plainly than any consultant could have. That candor turned out to be the most valuable data we collected. Decisions grounded in real feedback hold up under pressure in ways decisions grounded in assumptions do not.
People Support What They Help Create
An old line in organizational life goes: people support what they help create. It is true, but incomplete. People support what they can see they helped create.
That is why we built what we call the Community Voice Companion, a document published alongside the plan that maps what community members said, in their own words, to the plan language it shaped. A teacher can find the idea her group raised at the in-service and trace it to a specific commitment. A trustee can see where a board conversation became part of the framework. The companion turns participation from something symbolic into something people can check for themselves.
It may sound like a paradox, but using AI made this process more human, not less. By taking on synthesis, sorting, and summarizing, it freed people to do the listening, and it let far more voices count. Listening at this scale produces a mountain of material: chart paper and notes from in-service days, pages of written feedback, survey comments, and recorded retreat conversations. We used AI to help transcribe those sessions, sort the comments into themes, and flag where groups agreed and where they diverged. That work fed directly into the Community Voice Companion, letting us trace specific comments to specific plan language more quickly and completely than we could have by hand. What AI did not do was decide. Every theme was checked against people’s original words, and every choice about what made it into the plan, and what did not, was made by people who had to stand behind it. Used that way, AI did not replace the conversation. It helped us hear more of it.
It also includes a section titled “Voices Not Yet Fully Reflected.” Not every suggestion could become a priority, and pretending otherwise would have undone the trust the process was meant to build. Naming what did not make it, and why, tells people they were heard even when the answer was not yes. In our experience, explaining the reasoning behind a decision earns more commitment than the decision itself.
The shape of the plan helps. EXPLO Elevate’s 2-5-10 framework sets two non-negotiables; five critical ingredients essential to achieving them; and ten aspirational goals, the “wouldn’t it be wonderful if” items, where reaching six of ten would be a good result. That tiering gives a community room to dream while avoiding the risk of overpromising and underdelivering, and it gives leaders an honest way to say, “That matters, and here is where it sits.”
Easy Transparency Is a Leadership Practice
In many schools, transparency is treated as a heroic act: the rare moment when a leader opens the books or admits a mistake. We would rather make it the default, so ordinary that no one remarks on it.
That meant putting hard truths in the plan, not in a footnote. When a trustee reviewing a late draft observed that much of what the plan aspired to would require resources beyond what tuition alone can support, we did not soften the point. We added a fifth Critical Ingredient, Mobilizing Resources, that names it directly. The faculty told us they appreciated seeing financial health listed as the first non-negotiable. People rarely resist the truth. They resist being surprised by it. So share hard news early, while people still have time to help shape the response.
It also meant welcoming cynicism instead of managing it. When the approved plan went to faculty, the sharpest question was one every school leader has heard: Why is this time different? Earlier plans and facilities studies had come and gone without demonstrable action. We did not answer with a slogan. We gathered the feedback, synthesized it for the Leadership Team, matched each concern to the area of work responsible for it, and named the ones that did not yet have an owner.
Transparency clarifies governance, too. The process helped put the Board and the Leadership Team in their right lanes, and it made clear that accountability runs in both directions. The Board holds the school accountable to the non-negotiables and critical ingredients, and it also carries real responsibility for making them possible: leading the work of raising resources, and overseeing how those resources are allocated through its finance committee and the annual budget approval process. The Head of School and the team decide how to get there within that framework. When everyone knows whose decision is whose, difficult conversations become much easier.
Strategic Planning Should Never Be “Finished”
Ross often describes strategic planning through the America’s Cup. Before a race, the boats tack and jockey for position so they reach the starting line well placed. Then they race toward a buoy fixed in the water. A sailor who refuses to tack because the original plan said to sail straight will never reach the buoy. A sailor who loses sight of the buoy is simply drifting.
In Cheshire Academy’s plan, the non-negotiables, the critical ingredients, and the headings beneath them are the buoy. The bullet points below those headings are how we sail, and they will change as conditions change. The Board approved the whole plan knowing some of those bullets would be rewritten. That is not a weakness in the document. It is the design.
Keeping the conversation going takes structure, not simply good intentions. The school built checkpoints into its calendar, launched focused areas of work with named leaders in enrollment, fundraising, faculty talent and culture, and program distinction, and continues to gather feedback through recurring parent and employee surveys. Progress is measured against the plan, reported to the Board, and shared with the community.
The schools best positioned for the future are not necessarily those with the most ambitious plans. They are the ones whose communities understand their plans, believe in them, and help bring them to life.
Strategic Planning Is Leadership
So why is this time different? It is too early to declare victory, and we would be wary of anyone who did. But a few things are different, and we think they travel to any school.
The conversation came first. The plan grew out of 12 months of listening, and the community can see its fingerprints on the result.
The plan includes the hard truths. Resources are named as a critical ingredient, and the school has taken concrete steps, including engaging campaign counsel, that show the commitment is real.
The work is shared. At Cheshire Academy, we talk about building a progress culture: visible, incremental follow-through, momentum over perfection, and everyone owning a piece. A plan that depends on one person’s energy will not outlast that person’s calendar.
From our two vantage points, the leaders who do this well share a handful of habits. They listen before they decide. They build consensus, because people are more invested in what they help create. They communicate consistently and transparently, including when the news is not good. They measure progress and celebrate it. And they stay flexible without losing sight of the long-term vision.
A strategic plan does not succeed because it is well written. It succeeds when it becomes the framework for how leaders lead, and how a school makes decisions together. When the community has been a critical part of the conversation, and they understand it, believe in it, and feel it reflects their voice, plans are on course to succeed. The document records that conversation and gives it meaning and purpose. In this way, the conversation becomes the plan.
About the authors
Tom Woelper is Head of School at Cheshire Academy in Cheshire, Connecticut. He has more than 30 years of experience as a teacher, coach, academic leader, and head of school at independent schools in the United States and abroad.
Ross Peters is Founding Partner of EXPLO Elevate, where he advises heads of school and boards on strategy, governance, and leadership.